We all remember the Brown bounce after Gordon got coronated Labour leader. How long did that last…
Now, in the light of the forthcoming Glasgow East by-election, there is a new bounce. At least, that’s how the latest Times/Populus Poll (C 41 (-4), L 28 (+3), LD 19 (-1)) is being interpreted – and on the back of a YouGov poll showing a similar trend.
UK Polling Report’s Anthony Wells reckons it’s a recovery, as does Political Betting’s Mike Smithson.
The critical problems with these assumptions are (a) they assume Brown is winning some voters over and the trend may continue, and (b) it’s only +3.
Let’s face it. People think Brown is going – so the press and media tell them.
So they’re going to vote Labour (only +3). Brown actually going might add a few more points, but still leaves Labour with fewer than a third of voters supporting them.
All we need is further deepening economic gloom and more bad headlines for Labour and this +3 will unravel.
So it doesn’t matter who leads Labour: they’re done for. Brown isn’t going to go, even if he loses Glasgow East (which is lost as pointed out by Catholic composer James MacMillan in the Telegraph:
The recent parliamentary votes that defeated amendments to ban human-animal embryos, the creation of “saviour siblings”, and to reduce the abortion time limit did not go down well in places such as Glasgow East.
The votes of Labour MPs reflected the party’s one-sided approach to these issues and their hostility towards many in Scotland who are concerned about the dignity of human life, at all stages.
The party in London organised and advertised events to campaign on one side of the argument, in what was meant to be an issue of conscience, not party politics.
On the issue of late abortions after 20 or 22 weeks, this campaigning seemed to be seriously out of step with public opinion in Scotland, where there is a different and independent culture of ethical thinking on these matters.
The issue was going to be potent at the next general and Scottish parliamentary elections in any case, but suddenly there is to be a by-election in working-class Scotland, where there are lots of Catholic voters.
Most Catholics have so far resisted voting on single issues, seeing the pressing need for social justice across the board. To many old-style socialists, there is nothing more fundamental to a just and fair society than the protection of its most vulnerable members and their right to life.
The recent Commons vote represents a tipping point for many Labour voters in Scotland. Party numbers in both parliaments could soon be decimated.
Conor McGinn, the vice-chairman of Young Labour, resigned in protest at the growing anti-Catholic prejudice in the party, and its hostility towards the pro-life movement. The party in Scotland has had the long support of swaths of the Catholic electorate.
Helen Liddell almost lost John Smith’s Monklands East seat in the 1994 by-election (a big swing to the SNP) due to Labour’s discrimination against the Protestants of Airdrie. Now Labour is completely out of tune with the Catholics of East Glasgow, and with the Government so deeply unpopular and the SNP on an “extended honeymoon” as First Minister Alex Salmond himself says, Glasgow East will fall.
Last summer there was a Brown bounce. This summer there’s a Brown-going-out bounce. Sorry, folks, he’s going nowhere.
Your right of reply